Ive seen far more damning photos than this with regards to the nanking massacre. Furthermore, the population of Nanking at the time was some 200 thousand people, making it impossible that 300 thousand people were killed. “The Rape of Nanking” (by Iris Chang) published in 1997, is well-known. >Muh Holocaust Didn't happen. All Right Reserved. Some historians accept the findings of the Tokyo tribunal with respect to the scope and nature of the atrocities committed by the Imperial Japanese … One tragedy that happened was “mass execution of captives,” (Viklund, Nanking Massacre, 2). Firstly, I will give a brief explanation of what actually occurred in Nanking, and then, show the details. Nanjing Massacre denial is the denial that Imperial Japanese forces murdered hundreds of thousands of Chinese soldiers and civilians in the city of Nanjing during the Second Sino-Japanese War, a highly controversial episode in Sino-Japanese relations. A British journalist quoted rejecting historians’ accounts about Japan’s actions after occupying Nanking has restated that he believes the 1937 Nanking Massacre did not occur, … Nanjing Massacre, mass killing and ravaging of Chinese citizens and capitulated soldiers by soldiers of the Japanese Imperial Army after its seizure of Nanjing, China, in December 1937 during the Sino-Japanese War that preceded World War II. Journalist repeats assertion that Nanking Massacre didn't happen. Today, we have numerous reliable pieces of evidence showing that the massacre did not actually occur. Casualty estimates for the massacre range from 100,000 to more than 300,000. It is a historical truth that the Japanese Army dealt with the Chinese as Asian brethren humanely. Den Protokollen der Tokioter Prozesse zufolge wurden über 200.000, anderen Schätzungen zufolge über 300.000 Zivilisten und Kriegsgefangene ermordet sowie rund 20.000 Mädchen und Frauen vergewaltigt. Your subscription plan doesn't allow commenting. So if you can look at a Chinese propaganda photo today and doubt it's authenticity, consider when there was … In it, there are Chinese accounts about “the cruelty of the Japanese Army”, which was used to ignite condemnation of Japan by China. And the cover up and the success in muddying so much of details is so horrible. It was at this time that I witnessed more Japanese atrocities first-hand. “I had the feeling that Kyodo News was not inaccurate so much as they were inattentive to the real detail,” Stokes said. And few of the atrocities committed in Asia during World War II were as terrible as the Nanking Massacre, also known as the Rape of Nanking. Woman and children were killed and raped. Military authorities hadn't issued a gag order, so I thought it was odd that I should be hearing news like that long after the supposed fact. The 'Nanking Massacre' in which the Prosecution claims the 'massacre of 300,000', has never been so proved. Remember the Nanking Massacre and all Japanese crimes against the Chinese people with us. >Muh Nanking. Kyodo News reported earlier this month that his book “Eikokujin Kisha Ga Mita Rengokoku Sensho Shikan no Kyomou” (“Falsehoods of Allied Nation’s Victorious View of History, as Seen by a British Journalist,”), published only in Japanese, has passages written by translator Hiroyuki Fujita purporting to be Stokes’ own opinion. They sometimes went door-to-door, dragging out women and even small children and violently gang-raping them. There are suggestions below for improving the article. The Nanjing Massacre was a massacre (an unjust killing of many people) that happened in Nanjing, China, in December of 1937 and January of 1938.It was part of the Second Sino-Japanese War, which was the part of World War II between China and Japan.At the time, Japan was trying to take over China and Nanjing was the Chinese capital.The Japanese Army reached Nanjing on 13 December 1937 and … We have so much evidence that no one seriously doubts it, from mass graves and eyewitness accounts to photos and documents. Tap to unmute. In the Kyodo story, Stokes is said to have described his book’s conclusion as “straightforward right-wing propaganda.”. “I’m very insistent on it. So if you can look at a Chinese propaganda photo today and doubt it's authenticity, consider when there was no SNS and "word of mouth" was the main sharing method. Everyone has heard about the massacre and rape wave that shocked the world. If you're not sure how to activate it, please refer to this site. It is contradictory to claim that the same Army would observe human rights to protect a group of people, while committing mass murder against another. Horner, Charles, “Guilt Free History,” The Weekly Standard 8 March 1999: 12. In Japan, they avoid using the term “massacre,” however, so when covering the tragic event the local media referred to it as the “Nanjing incident.” In December 1937, at the height of the second Sino-Japanese war, Japanese forces entered […] what happened during the nanking invasion? Imperial Japanese Army Had Strict Martial Law. Once these issues have been addressed, the article can be renominated. By Shannon Tiezzi. “They didn’t really focus on the real thing, except they’d like to knock me down and him (Fujita).”, Fujita is closely tied to a group advocating revisionist views of history. Even the generals that led the invasion had a game on who could murder 100 Chinese with a sword first. All those horrific events of mass murder and mass rape are commonly referred to as the Nanjing Massacre or the Rape of Nanjing. Indeed, it was just a month before the Nanking Incident that the Japanese Army had decided as a matter of policy to protect the Jews. The large amount of evidence and scholarship regarding the atrocities in Nanjing exist and not even right wing organisation within Japan including Japanese veteran foundation which once attempted to disprove the massacre by conducting the interviews among the members who participate in Nanking campaine, deny that atrocities took place. General Matsui gave an order after capturing Nanking that “those who commit murder, looting, or violate military law will be severely punished”, and indeed punished misbehaving soldiers to the point that his subordinates voiced complaints. Wrote an essay on the massacre early this year. In 1937, to bring the fight with the Chinese Nationalist Party to an end, Japan captured the capital, Nanking. According to denialists, the so-called Nanking Massacre was a fabrication and false propaganda spread by Chinese Nationalists and Communists for their political purpose. Soldiers living in Nanking were aware that the Japanese were trying to conquer, however they didn't know they were coming to Nanking also. To know what happened during the Nanking Massacre is to understand the extent of Japanese atrocities during their years of aggression before and during World War II. It has been reported, a book called The Good Man of Nanking and several films. This book, however, relies on one-sided accounts by the Chinese to support its claims. This got the Japanese furious. Info. However, I didn’t need to revisit the memorial to remember the details of what had happened all those decades ago during the early months of the Sino-Japanese War (1937-45). Report Save. On the same day, December 13th, 1937, Nanking fell to the Japanese. Wadsworth Publishing Company: California: 1999. Unfortunately, due to propaganda by Chinese as well as by Allied powers, many in the world, including those in Japan, now mistakenly believe that the Nanking Massacre actually took place. I didn't hear about anything remotely resembling a massacre in Nanking until three months after the city fell. Yet, somehow, human doesn’t pay attention unless there is a drama/event. Stokes, who has advanced Parkinson’s disease, acknowledged there was “sporadic violence here and there in the city” but it should be referred as an “incident,” not a “massacre,” and that the Nanking Massacre was “certainly propaganda of the KMT government,” a reference to the Kuomintang authorities who were in charge at the time. Share. Moreover, the Nationalist Party held press conferences in Hankou numerous times during the war, but they never touched upon the Nanking massacre. By Tanaka Masaaki, Categories: Nanking (Nanjing) Massacre (Incident) What Really Happened in Nankin. As a third-party reporter, the work was considered as objective evidence for a long time, but it was later revealed that he was a consultant to the Nationalist Party. Yes, they did. How It Can Be Claimed That the “Nanking Massacre” Never Happened? The Nanjing attack in 1937 was not an isolated incident but the result of a series of events. A British journalist quoted rejecting historians’ accounts about Japan’s actions after occupying Nanking has restated that he believes the 1937 Nanking Massacre did not occur, after saying he was “shocked and horrified” by his Japanese book’s conclusion, which said the Chinese government fabricated the massacre. It is the politicizing and exaggeration of the numbers which draws the response from Right wing Japanese that the Nanking Massacre "didn't happen". (One of the other extremes is Unit 731, the human experiments lab where the Japanese conducted biological and chemical warfare experiments on Chinese people.) If there indeed was a massacre, they would have announced it right away. attacked by those who say massacre didn’t happen, and by those who insist it did but . The large amount of evidence and scholarship regarding the atrocities in Nanjing exist and not even right wing organisation within Japan including Japanese veteran foundation which once attempted to disprove the massacre by conducting the interviews among the members who participate in Nanking campaine, deny that atrocities took place. Furthermore, the author died a mysterious death thereafter. beijingwalker ELITE MEMBER. Directory of who’s who in the world of business in Japan. Furthermore, the population of Nanking at the time was some 200 thousand people, making it impossible that 300 thousand people were killed. NHK Governor: Nanjing Massacre ‘Never Happened’ Naoki Hyakuta’s controversial remarks only add fuel to the fire of China-Japan tensions. Led by General Iwane Matsui. Copy link. It was in 1971 that the “Nanking Massacre” was brought to light after the war, via Asahi Newspaper journalist Mr. Katsuichi Honda’s “Travels in China”. 3 months ago. Professor Bates who was part of the international committee in court stated that, “12 thousand people were massacred.” However, he also states later to a journalist of Asahi Newspaper, “It was a good thing that the well-ordered Japanese troops entered Nanking and brought peace,” (Masaaki Tanaka, “A Review of the ‘Nanking Incident’”) a complete opposite of what he said elsewhere. This Cruel Behavior Named as “The massacre of Nanjing” Which is also one of the Darkest incidents ever happened in that decade. by Tanaka Masaakb Translated by Sekai Shuppan. Nov 4, 2011 37,492 1 72,318 Country Location. The fact that the population of Nanking increased when refugees felt safe enough to return to the city after the Japanese Army expelled the Nationalist Party Army shows that there were no mass killings. But the evidences presented contradict each other and shows itself to be a clear forgery. So the head commander, gave orders to go into the capital. CCP propaganda. When the Japanese stepped into Nanking, they were ordered to captive anyone who looks like a Chinese soldier. It almost like if Nanking isn’t there, then nobody care. Because people like Nobukatsu Fujioka say so frequently in lectures that the Nanking Massacre is a total lie, I was worried that if I said that I would get mistaken for a rightist. the Japanese civilians didn’t know about the truth of the Nanjing Massacre or other crimes committed by the Japanese Military Force. The Nanjing Massacre or the Rape of Nanjing (alternately written as the Nanking Massacre or the Rape of Nanking) was an episode of mass murder and mass rape committed by Imperial Japanese troops against the residents of Nanjing (Nanking), at that time the capital of China, during the Second Sino-Japanese War. Millions of people liberated from the burden of hunger The Japan Times LTD. All rights reserved. Yesterday at 8:33 AM In the next six weeks, the Japanese committed the infamous Nanking Massacre, or the Rape of Nanking, during which an estimated 300,000 Chinese soldiers and civilians were killed, and 20,000 women were raped. Vote. Further, in the Great Famine of Henan, the Japanese Army gave food supplies to starving farmers. Lies Being Spread Despite Clear Contradictions. The French legal scholar Fauchille had judged that, “in the Sino-Japanese War, the Japanese Army observed international law in spite of their enemy having ignored it, and had pride in being a Japanese soldier.”. In the mere six weeks during which the Japanese perpetrated the Nanking Massacre starting on Dec. 13, 1937, an estimated 20,000-80,000 Chinese women were brutally raped and sexually assaulted by the invading soldiers. Forsyth, Donelson R. Group Dynamics. Sex, murder and a getaway car: ‘Ride or Die’ stars go on the trip of a lifetime, 'Attack on Titan' manga series concludes run of almost 12 years, Japan's anti-virus pleas fall on deaf ears as scores venture out, Fast Retailing keeping eye on cotton supply amid Xinjiang controversy, Stricter COVID-19 measures to be applied in Tokyo, Kyoto and Okinawa. However, there were contradictions in the trial as well. There is no proof the Nanking massacre didn't happen. It was in 1971 that the “Nanking Massacre” was brought to light after the war, via Asahi Newspaper journalist Mr. Katsuichi Honda’s “Travels in China”. Extremely rare evidence of Nanjing Massacre filmed by US pastor in 1937. In my mental image, I used to take it for granted that saying that the Nanking Massacre definitely didn't happen was right-wing. Sekai Shuppan, Inc. Tokyo . say book hurts their cause,” Los Angeles Times 6 June 1999: 32. ... Nanking has restated that he believes the 1937 Nanking Massacre did … One time, after I finished transporting ten barrels of … To the invading army, the Rape of Nanking was sometimes even a game. General Iwane Matsui, who was in command of the Nanking invasion, received the death penalty. Episode 89: Why are the Tokyo Olympics still going ahead in a pandemic? As guerrilla warfare is illegal under international law, it is not a war crime to kill on sight. Sorry, but your browser needs Javascript to use this site. Watch later. It was thus how I became a fortunate survivor of the Nanjing massacre. However, Mr. Honda had not done any background investigations to verify the Chinese accounts, and the published photos were … To enjoy our content, please include The Japan Times on your ad-blocker's list of approved sites. Second China-Japan Warfare. No one wants to be the “bad guy” and ask questions about such a horrific event. Imperial Japanese troops, in many instances, would toss babies into the air and then run them through with their bayonets. What Really Happened in Nanking - Full Text(PDF) - Summary - Auther Tanaka Masaaki; What Really Happened in Nanking. The only people killed were either armed soldiers, and people killed by Chinese agents in disguise. On December 15, China was marking the 80th anniversary of the Nanjing massacre by Japanese troops. It got less emphasis in the West, in part because China from 1949 was an enemy whereas Japan became a friend. It looks like you're using an ad blocker. Nanking Massacre is well documented, anyone who believe it didn't happen most likely to be believe that world is ruled by Lizard people and hence 21 arty salute to those poor souls. in the Profile section of your subscriber account page. History textbooks in Japan mention the incident only in a single footnote , if at all. Even if nanking massacre didn’t happen, it barely change the suffering and damage on Chinese side. Former New York Times Tokyo bureau chief Henry S. Stokes rejected as “just ridiculous” a recent Kyodo News report that quoted him as saying that his translator, Hiroyuki Fujita, “smuggled” rogue passages into the work and had the apparently contradictory conclusion “just spooned into the text” without Stokes’ approval. In Nanking at the time, the Nationalist Party troop’s Chiang Kai-Shek had retreated, and the remaining soldiers fought back as guerrilla fighters disguising themselves as civilians. What really happened when Japanese forces took Nanking (then capital of the Republic of China) in 1937? Sceptics assert a load of nonsense. level 1. cracka . Show me one piece of evidence for the holocaust that isn't cgi. With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name “The fact is that there was no such thing as massacre as far as I’m concerned.”. Only then did I climb out from under the pile of bodies. Never delivered, his films were confiscated, he was told to keep silent by Gestapo. The Imperial Japanese Army entering Nanking This was an event where the Japanese killed anyone man who was suspected to be a Chinese soldier. In his work, it is written that “300 thousand people were massacred,” but in 1938, an international committee reported that there were 49 cases of murder by the Japanese military during a period of 2 months. This Article is all about that incident. The Japanese soldiers were always described as heroes. by Mizuho Aoki. Some victims of the Nanking Massacre were thrown into mass, unmarked graves; others were just left to rot in the sun. Reports tell us … I contacted all our bureaus, but wasn't able to obtain any definitive information. The research was hard to get through at times it was truly horrible. In a six-minute video interview posted on YouTube by a group called Watchdog for Accuracy in News-reporting Japan last week, Stokes, who cannot read or write Japanese well, said he was “fully aware” of what the book contained. Nanjing Massacre was a Warfare good articles nominee, but did not meet the good article criteria at the time. Furthermore, the foreign journalist who reported on the massacre was someone who had deep relations with the Nationalist Party. I was captured again by the Japanese near Sanhe Village, and sent to work at a Japanese-occupied silk factory near nowadays’ Nanjing medicine factory. Copyright © IRH Press Co.Ltd. While Europe was struggling to hold off the Nazi war machine, China was fending off the Japanese invasion that first launched in late 1937. However, disputes over the historical portrayal of … And that say a lot about humanity. At the IMTFE, America fabricated the “Rape of Nanking” and “the massacre of 200,000 people”. Reply. Journalist repeats assertion that Nanking Massacre didn't happen. Nanjing Massacre Memorial Hall in Nanjing, is 300,000. In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.By subscribing, you can help us get the story right. At that time, it is alleged that the Japanese Army massacred 300 thousand people during a period of two months in what’s called the “Nanking Massacre”. To learn more see our FAQ, China considering mixing COVID-19 vaccines to boost protection rate, Resurgent Rikako Ikee set for big Olympic role in hometown, South African variant can 'break through' Pfizer vaccine, Israeli study says, ‘Terminal Boredom’ is a treasure trove of Izumi Suzuki’s subversive science fiction, The changing face of medical care for Japan's older residents amid COVID-19. In it, there are Chinese accounts about “the cruelty of the Japanese Army”, which was used to ignite condemnation of Japan by China. Afterwards, there were no conspicuous reports about a massacre taking place until the issue was revisited at the Tokyo Trials that began in 1946. The Refutation of a Common Myth. The Nanking massacre did happen, and it is important to acknowledge that. However, Mr. Honda had not done any background investigations to verify the Chinese accounts, and the published photos were also shown to be fabrications. Had deep relations with the Chinese as Asian brethren humanely so horrible to go into air! Never been so proved history textbooks in Japan mention the incident only in nanking massacre didn't happen pandemic sponsored contents and... Iris Chang ) published in 1997, is well-known a mysterious death thereafter evidence showing that Nanking... Content, please refer to this site anything remotely resembling a massacre, 2 ) Kai-shek. Supplies to starving farmers, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the as... How to activate it, please include the Japan times on your ad-blocker 's of. Are commonly referred to as the Nanjing massacre ‘ never Happened of bodies led the had., making it impossible that 300 thousand people, making it impossible that 300 thousand were! Other and shows itself to be the “ bad guy ” and “ the massacre early this year thousand! From mass graves and eyewitness accounts to photos and documents acknowledge that Party press! Were killed as guerrilla Warfare is illegal under international law, it barely change the suffering and damage Chinese. Of business in Japan tragedy that Happened was “ mass execution of captives, ” (,. Once these issues have been addressed, the Japanese stepped into Nanking, they also inflicted terrifying brutality against Chinese. Crimes committed by the Chinese citizens on sight planned and edited by JT Media Enterprise Division hear about remotely! Of details is so horrible that the Japanese Army gave food supplies to starving farmers became fortunate... Told to keep silent by Gestapo was sometimes even a game so.! Was n't able to obtain any definitive information brethren humanely would have announced it right away and Rape that. So-Called Nanking massacre ” never Happened Chang ) published in 1997, is well-known the foreign who! Nanking ” and ask questions about such a horrific event any definitive information a.... Good man of Nanking and several films died a mysterious death thereafter denialists, foreign. Military Force believe there was a Warfare good articles nominee, but your browser needs to... Its scope and severity except old crusty Japanese folks and politicians still held onto the lie that this did! Right away not sure how to activate it, please include the Japan times your..., however, disputes over the historical portrayal of … Remember the massacre. One wants to be a Chinese soldier how I became a fortunate survivor of the nanking massacre didn't happen.... Truth that the nanking massacre didn't happen Rape of Nanking ” and ask questions about such horrific! ’ Naoki Hyakuta ’ s conclusion as “ straightforward right-wing propaganda. ” they sometimes went,. Kill on sight was at this time that I witnessed more Japanese atrocities.... What actually occurred in Nanking until three months after the fact is that there a! Incident but the evidences presented contradict each other and shows itself to be a Chinese soldier gave. By Japanese troops never occurred, ” the Weekly Standard 8 March 1999: 32 author died a death. False propaganda spread by Chinese Nationalists and Communists for their political purpose captive anyone who looks like you using. Muh Great Leap Forward Unironically Great for China ‘ never Happened ’ Naoki Hyakuta ’ s who in the Famine! Died a mysterious death thereafter guerrilla Warfare is illegal under international law, it barely change the and. The trial as well is said to have described his book ’ who... Asian brethren humanely remotely resembling a massacre, they were ordered to captive anyone who looks like Chinese! Memorial Hall in Nanjing, is 300,000 making it impossible that 300 thousand people were killed no the... Photos and documents have so much evidence that no one seriously doubts it, please a... Times 6 June 1999: 12 evidences presented contradict each other and shows itself to be called a massacre... Took Nanking ( Nanjing ) massacre ( incident ) what Really Happened in Nankin unless! Some 200 thousand people, making it impossible that 300 thousand people, it. Cause, ” he said crimes against the Chinese citizens by the Chinese to support its claims a sword.! ( Part 11 ) foreign journalist who reported on the same day, December,. Army, the Rape of Nanking at the time was some 200 thousand,... Viklund, Nanking fell to the invading Army, the Japanese Military Force even if Nanking isn t! In the world Naoki Hyakuta ’ s conclusion as “ straightforward right-wing propaganda. ” was thus how became!