At least, it's a kdrama and not an American tv show where you invest between 6-10 years of your life into the characters.I feel like if the director had wanted Haram and Black to have some semblance of happiness, he should have change it to not have Haram as Joon's shooter (I'm still bitter about that). So it's all 444's fault?I really want to know what Choi Ran's problem is with her main male characters. Prevent Seon-young’s parents from dying in their car crash so she never became an orphan determined to become a doctor? I will say good-bye to all of you through ‘Black.’ This is a drama that allowed me to show you another side of myself as actor Song Seung Heon, so I think this is going to be an unforgettable drama to me. He liked Ha-Ram and all, but a) they’d have no reason to meet in the alternate life given she didn’t have her powers, and b) There was a stronger emotional connection between Man-Soo and Tiffany for me anyways, even before Black’s wipe out. Black doesn’t care if it means he’ll perish as a Reaper, he’s prepared to kill the congressman. Thank you to everyone who made unforgettable memories for me. (Uh, but wasn't that Moo-gang's body animated by Joon/Black's soul??) A complete complicated mess.One thing i really disliked in this show was the police/detective team. Did Moo-gang become an accountant in America when there was no need for his mother to send him away in the first place?

Hearing about how Choi Ran had enough for 20 episodes and how the director messed with her endng, I understand why it was messy.I thought it was interesting that Haram became an EMT. Soo-wan says if Joon’s mother is truly sorry, then she can make it up to her by moving to America with Soo-wan.Black goes to the columbarium and pours the ashes from Joon’s urn into the nearly empty urn of Seung-chul (since when there’s only a hand to bury, there aren’t many ashes). Grim Reaper 444 takes over the body of Detective Han Moo-gang.
But I think Joon/Black should still have SSH's appearance because Joon's heart was in Moo Gang's body; so that in a way Moo Gang's body was also his. And that's why it's so dissatisfying, because they're not committing to anything.Then there's the myriad of issues that pop up with how nonsensical it is, such as Black's reaper friend somehow still remembering Black and protecting Ha-Ram by her side. (several months or a year after their wedding, i suggest, to make it more dramatic),4.

And the whackjob arsonist who killed his wife for the life insurance payout would not have been stopped, IIRC. This is still confusing.

It just doesn't make any sense.

Even MooGang would have got the heart transplant from that other girl so everyone would have lived & the Time Mart collapse problem would have been solved immediately w the tapes. He should not have changed choi ran's ending.The ending in God's gift was sad because she killed jo seung woo there but it made sense.. and people somehow deluded themselves that it was an open ending, that somehow ki dong chan was alive.If black was meant to stop existing as the writer wanted then I'll accept it as it is, but rewriting ha ram's life just doesn't make sense. Black points out that he had to be cruel to Ha-ram so she would leave him alone. How the heck is that bracelet still exist?

Just the writers that need to know how to polish off a script. If the soul who happened to be 444 didn't exist either, then Black shouldn't exist at the end. Can we add a reconcilitation scene between original Moo-gang (peeking from heaven) and adult Joon so we can at least see Song Seung-heon's face in the finale? The end is finally here, and it’s time to see how our characters deal with the consequences of their actions from twenty years ago. Joon/Black wasn't just about Ha Ram. Thus Haram never knew who Joon was in her new life. Was it an after effect of the first timeline?

After that, the couple hardly had any romance time and it was like the whole "dating" thing never happened. Again, i would say that Black is a brilliant series. They did find footage of someone jumping off the cliff where they found Joon’s body, and they realize that it must be Black.Everyone is shocked, but none more so than Ha-ram.In the Underworld, Black stands trial before the Death Squad. Is Kwang-kyun still alive and having his own happily-ever-after with Clara?

Give us that encounter with Black where she learns the truth and has the chance to move past it. "is driving me almost as crazy as attempting to figure out what the hell kind of Halloween-Christmas holiday old Leo and old Ha-ram were celebrating." I was rooting for the two since the early episodes because I liked their chemistry. Come on kdrama, can u just break the cliche?Was that an actual reference to Goodbye, Mr Black?

And even worse, now there's nobody there to clear up the case. Moo-gang fainted before Soo-wan and felt his heart beating wildly.

Yes it made it difficult to sympathise with her at times but at least she wasn't this noble, virginal, not-very-bright champion of justice like every other female lead.My problem is with the implication that Ha Ram and her happiness was the entire point of the drama.
It’s not just the laughably terrible high school drama makeup they did to make twentysomethings Go Ara and Kim Jae-young look older. She tries to run and hide, but she’s no match for Missing-finger.

Hong Kong? But she only knew Moo Gang for a couple of days before his death so I didn't see how that was a happy ending. Comedy suits him.